Student Loans and Mortgages: What You Need to Know
Turning Student Debt Into a Clear Financial Picture
You’ve worked hard to earn your education, and now you’re ready to buy a home. If you still have student loans, you might wonder whether they could keep you from qualifying for a mortgage. The good news is that student loans are rarely a deal-breaker. They are just one factor lenders look at when deciding how much house you can afford.
Even if your student loan is in deferment, most lenders still count a monthly payment in your debt-to-income ratio, or DTI. The tricky part is that each loan program has its own rules. That means the same $75,000 loan balance could be treated very differently depending on whether you apply for a VA, FHA, USDA, or Conventional loan.
Let’s walk through each loan type and then see how it works in a real example.
VA Loans
VA loans are flexible with student debt, but only veterans or active-duty service members qualify. If your student loan is deferred for at least 12 months after closing, the lender does not count it in your DTI at all. If it isn’t deferred that long, the lender counts either your actual monthly payment or a standard formula of 5% of the balance divided by 12 months, whichever is higher.
FHA Loans
FHA loans use either the monthly payment shown on your credit report (or the documented payment from your loan servicer) if it is above zero, or 0.5% of the outstanding balance if the credit report shows zero.
USDA Loans
USDA loans are only available for approved rural properties. Lenders include your student loan payment in your DTI, which generally must stay at 41% or less of your gross income. For deferred or forbearance loans, lenders use the higher of 0.5% of the loan balance or the actual payment listed on the credit report.
Fannie Mae (FNMA) Conventional Loans
Fannie Mae allows lenders to use the monthly payment listed on your credit report. If that number is wrong, they can use your student loan statement instead. If your credit report shows $0 and you are on an income-driven plan, the lender may use $0 if they can verify it. For deferred or forbearance loans, the lender must either use 1% of the balance or calculate a fully amortizing payment using the loan’s terms.
Freddie Mac (FHLMC) Conventional Loans
Freddie Mac works slightly differently. If your credit report shows a payment above zero, that is what the lender must use unless better documentation is available. If the credit report shows zero, the lender uses 0.5% of the balance. For income-driven repayment plans where the payment may increase soon, the lender uses the higher of the current payment or 0.5% of the balance, or the documented future payment once it is approved.
Mortgage Lending Explained is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Why On-Time Payments Matter
Regardless of the type of loan you choose, making student loan payments on time is crucial. Late payments appear on your credit report and can lower your FICO score. Since your credit score plays a significant role in qualifying for a mortgage, too many late payments could hurt your chances, even if your income and debts meet the guidelines.
Loan Forgiveness
If your student loan has been completely forgiven, it will not be included in your DTI. The key is proof. You must provide documentation directly from your loan servicer or employer showing the forgiveness is final. Without that paperwork, the lender will have to count the debt.
Let’s Look at an Example
Meet Sarah. She has a $75,000 student loan balance and is ready to buy her first home. Depending on the type of mortgage she chooses, her monthly student loan payment can look very different to the lender.
If Sarah chooses a VA loan and her student loan is deferred for at least 12 months after closing, her payment won’t be counted at all. If it isn’t deferred that long, the lender counts 5% of her balance divided by 12, which comes out to about $312 a month.
With an FHA loan, the lender looks at either the payment reported on her credit report or 0.5% of her balance if the report shows zero. That would be around $375 a month unless her credit report shows a higher number.
If Sarah chooses a USDA loan, the lender includes her student loan in her debt-to-income ratio. For deferred loans, they use the higher of 0.5% of the balance or the credit report payment, which would again be at least $375 a month.
For a Fannie Mae conventional loan, the lender can use her actual payment if it is reported. If her loan is deferred or in forbearance, they could use 1% of the balance, which would come to $750 a month.
With a Freddie Mac conventional loan, if the credit report shows zero, the lender uses 0.5% of the balance, or $375 per month, unless the payment is being recertified and set to increase; in this case, the higher documented payment is used.
As you can see, the same $75,000 student loan can be treated very differently depending on the program. Knowing how each lender counts the debt helps Sarah, as well as anyone in her situation, plan and choose the best mortgage option.
The Bottom Line
The same $75,000 student loan can count as nothing, a few hundred dollars, or even as much as $750, depending on the program. That difference can make or break your ability to qualify.
If you have student loans and plan to buy a home, discuss this with your loan officer early. Ask them to show you how each program counts your student debt so you know your options. The rules may be confusing, but understanding them gives you a clearer path to becoming a homeowner.
Thanks for reading Mortgage Lending Explained! This post is public, so feel free to share it.
